EFL Championship
Apr 5, 2024
Rotherham
0 - 1
Plymouth
Dec 16, 2023
Plymouth
3 - 2
Rotherham
Feb 12, 2005
Plymouth
1 - 1
Rotherham
Oct 19, 2004
Rotherham
0 - 1
Plymouth
League One
Feb 26, 2022
Plymouth
0 - 1
Rotherham
Aug 7, 2021
Rotherham
2 - 0
Plymouth
Apr 28, 2018
Plymouth
2 - 1
Rotherham
Dec 16, 2017
Rotherham
1 - 1
Plymouth
League Two
Apr 20, 2013
Plymouth
0 - 1
Rotherham
Oct 27, 2012
Rotherham
1 - 0
Plymouth
Mar 10, 2012
Rotherham
1 - 0
Plymouth
Aug 13, 2011
Plymouth
1 - 4
Rotherham
