May 18, 2025
Columbus Crew 2
1 - 0
Sep 15, 2024
Cincinnati 2
2 - 1
Jul 21, 2024
Columbus Crew 2
6 - 1
May 12, 2024
Columbus Crew 2
0 - 1
Sep 17, 2023
Cincinnati 2
0 - 4
Aug 19, 2023
Columbus Crew 2
5 - 1
May 21, 2023
Cincinnati 2
0 - 1
Sep 18, 2022
Columbus Crew 2
9 - 0
Aug 14, 2022
Cincinnati 2
7 - 5
Jul 16, 2022
Columbus Crew 2
4 - 0